Promotion
Use code DAD23 for 20% off + Free shipping on $45+ Shop Now!
The Battle of Blair Mountain
The Story Of America's Largest Labor Uprising
Contributors
Formats and Prices
Price
$11.99Price
$15.99 CADFormat
Format:
- ebook $11.99 $15.99 CAD
- Trade Paperback $16.99 $22.99 CAD
This item is a preorder. Your payment method will be charged immediately, and the product is expected to ship on or around July 26, 2006. This date is subject to change due to shipping delays beyond our control.
Also available from:
Excerpt
PRAISE FOR THE BATTLE OF BLAIR MOUNTAIN
"From atop Blair Mountain, Robert Shogan has conjured a vivid vision of modern America in the making in the bloody coal field struggles of 1920s West Virginia. Infused with the humane intelligence of one of our most distinguished political correspondents, this haunting tale restores a shocking chapter of American history to its rightful place in this nation's unfolding saga of democratic aspirations and shattered dreams. It is a rare gem of a book."
—JOSEPH A. McCARTIN, Georgetown University, author of
Labor's Great War
Labor's Great War
"Robert Shogan sheds new light on this long-neglected episode of the labor movement's ongoing struggle for workers' rights. For too long, the significant Battle of Blair Mountain has been merely a footnote in American history books. Now, the real story of America's largest labor uprising—and the largest armed insurrection on U.S. soil since the Civil War—comes alive. As a native of Cabin Creek, W.Va.—and the great-nephew of the miners' commander, Bill Blizzard—I take personal interest in reading about my union's pivotal role in this historic rebellion for economic and social justice."
—CECIL ROBERTS, president, United Mine Workers of America
"Bob Shogan has covered seven presidents and countless political campaigns. Now he tells the story of a forgotten chapter of American history—an armed uprising by 10,000 West Virginia coal miners against the coal companies that dominated their lives, exploited their labor, and controlled their state government. This book is a riveting refutation of the comforting conventional wisdom that there has never been class struggle in America."
—DAVID KUSNET, chief speechwriter for former president
Bill Clinton (1992–1994), and author of Speaking American:
How the Democrats Can Win in the Nineties
Bill Clinton (1992–1994), and author of Speaking American:
How the Democrats Can Win in the Nineties
"Here is a book about forgotten events that took place 80 years ago in a little understood corner of our nation. What a surprise that Bob Shogan has not only found ample documentary evidence to convince us of the historical significance of these battles between miners and mine owners in southern WV, but also spun a rip roaring tale full of shockingly vivid and down-to-earth portraits. When the tale is told, Shogan's conclusion seems irrefutable: our nation paid a heavy price in economic justice and social progress when state and federal authorities failed to ensure workers' basic freedom to form unions."
—RICHARD L. TRUMKA, Secretary-Treasurer, AFL-CIO, and
Past President, United Mine Workers of America
Past President, United Mine Workers of America
shocking chapter of American history to its rightful place in this nation's unfolding saga of democratic aspirations and shattered dreams. It is a rare gem of a book."
—JOSEPH A. McCARTIN, Georgetown University,
author of Labor's Great War
author of Labor's Great War
"Robert Shogan sheds new light on this long-neglected episode of the labor movement's ongoing struggle for workers' rights. For too long, the significant Battle of Blair Mountain has been merely a footnote in American history books. Now, the real story of America's largest labor uprising—and the largest armed insurrection on U.S. soil since the Civil War—comes alive. As a native of Cabin Creek, W.Va.—and the great-nephew of the miners' commander, Bill Blizzard—I take personal interest in reading about my union's pivotal role in this historic rebellion for economic and social justice."
—CECIL ROBERTS, president, United Mine Workers of America
"Bob Shogan has covered seven presidents and countless political campaigns. Now he tells the story of a forgotten chapter of American history—an armed uprising by 10,000 West Virginia coal miners against the coal companies that dominated their lives, exploited their labor, and controlled their state government. This book is a riveting refutation of the comforting conventional wisdom that there has never been class struggle in America."
—DAVID KUSNET, chief speechwriter for former president
Bill Clinton (1992–1994), and author of Speaking American:
How the Democrats Can Win in the Nineties
Bill Clinton (1992–1994), and author of Speaking American:
How the Democrats Can Win in the Nineties
"Here is a book about forgotten events that took place 80 years ago in a little understood corner of our nation. What a surprise that Bob Shogan has not only found ample documentary evidence to convince us of the historical significance of these battles between miners and mine owners in southern WV, but also spun a rip roaring tale full of shockingly vivid and down-to-earth portraits. When the tale is told, Shogan's conclusion seems irrefutable: our nation paid a heavy price in economic justice and social progress when state and federal authorities failed to ensure workers' basic freedom to form unions."
—RICHARD L. TRUMKA, Secretary-Treasurer, AFL-CIO, and
Past President, United Mine Workers of America
Past President, United Mine Workers of America
OTHER WORKS BY ROBERT SHOGAN
War Without End
Cultural Conflict and the
Struggle for America's Political Future
Cultural Conflict and the
Struggle for America's Political Future
Bad News
Where the Press Goes
Wrong in the Making of the President
Where the Press Goes
Wrong in the Making of the President
The Double-Edged Sword
How Character Makes and Ruins
Presidents From Washington to Clinton
How Character Makes and Ruins
Presidents From Washington to Clinton
Fate of the Union
America's Rocky Road to Political Stalemate
America's Rocky Road to Political Stalemate
Hard Bargain
How FDR Twisted Churchill's Arm, Evaded the
Law and Changed the Role of the American Presidency
How FDR Twisted Churchill's Arm, Evaded the
Law and Changed the Role of the American Presidency
Riddle of Power
Presidential Leadership From Truman to Bush
Presidential Leadership From Truman to Bush
None of the Above
Why Presidents Fail and What Can Be Done About It
Why Presidents Fail and What Can Be Done About It
Promises to Keep
Carter's First 100 Days
Carter's First 100 Days
A Question of Judgment
The Fortas Case and the Struggle for the Supreme Court
The Fortas Case and the Struggle for the Supreme Court
The Detroit Race Riot
A Study in Violence (With Tom Craig)
A Study in Violence (With Tom Craig)
For Ellen
Author's Note
"Labor, like Israel, has many sorrows," John L. Lewis observed during his reign as president of the United Mine Workers. "Its women weep for their fallen and they lament for the future of the race." Among labor's many costly defeats, the Battle of Blair Mountain arguably ranks as the most neglected.
When I first became interested in the Battle of Blair Mountain in the early 1960s, I thought it remarkable that so little had been written about this unprecedented episode in our development as a nation. The course of my professional life then took me in a different direction. When I returned to the subject, nearly four decades later, I found that more work had been done, all of it creditable. Yet the great uprising of the West Virginia miners remains only an afterthought in our historical consciousness, earning only a few sentences at most even in chronicles of the labor movement and no attention at all in more general accounts of the American heritage. This book is intended to help remedy this oversight. By looking into this dark corner of American history my hope is to cast light on the forces that shaped the American political and economic order in the 20th century and give the ordeal of the southern West Virginia miners its proper place in the story of our nation.
One reason for the continued obscurity of this episode up to now is our country's dominant middle-class ethos. This frame of reference discourages attention to struggles to achieve social and economic justice, if they threaten the sanctity of property values and the maintenance of law and order. As a result the significance of class conflict in the making of America is overlooked and misunderstood.
When the union coal miners confronted their adversaries, the 20th century had barely begun. The makings were already in place but had yet to assume the established pattern of the power structure we know today. Economic advantage and political control were up for grabs, in a no-holds-barred clash between business and labor. Both had emerged from the Great War bolder and brawnier than before, each eager for more, neither willing to give ground. Those were cruder times than now, with a good deal less artifice. With so much at stake the leaders on each side did not shrink from stating they intended to crush their enemies and from backing their rhetoric with action.
In West Virginia, where the level of hostility and violence between business and labor reached its zenith, the coal operators condemned the United Mine Workers union, the largest and most powerful in the country, as "revolutionary in character and a menace to the free institutions of the country." To meet this threat they deployed a private army of detectives and sheriff's deputies. And during one particularly bitter and bloody strike that set the stage for the Battle of Blair Mountain, the mine owners dispatched a special train, rigged with iron plate and bristling with machine guns to assault a tent colony that sheltered the strikers and their families.
For their part, the union leaders vilified not only the mine operators but the politicians who catered to their greed. "You can expect no help from such a goddam dirty coward," Mother Jones, one of the UMW's most ferocious organizers, told a crowd of union men who massed in the state's capital to seek the governor's support in their travail. "But I warn this little governor that unless he gets rid of these goddam Baldwin-Felts mine guard thugs there is going to be one hell of a lot of bloodletting in these hills." She was right about that. For years the union miners and the allies of the coal operators spilled each other's blood in the West Virginia hills until the miners were beaten into submission.
Though no such despotism as flourished in West Virginia in the 1920s survives today, the struggle between working people and their adversaries for political power and economic advantage rages on, and I believe the conflict in West Virginia provides lessons that illuminate the new battlegrounds of the 21st century.
Robert Shogan
CHEVY CHASE, MARYLAND
JANUARY 2004
CHEVY CHASE, MARYLAND
JANUARY 2004
THE FIELDS OF BATTLE
1
Matewan Station
ON A DREARY morning in May of 1920 seven men carrying Winchesters and pistols boarded the Norfolk and Western's No. 29 at Bluefield, West Virginia, bound for the little mining town of Matewan on the Kentucky border. All were hirelings of the Baldwin-Felts detective agency, personally selected by their boss, Tom Felts. Half a dozen or so others would follow by later trains. Nearly all "have been tried and can be relied on," Tom Felts had written to his brother, Albert, who was already posted in Matewan.
The railroad that transported the agents to Matewan was part of the reason for their mission. More than thirty years before, the well-tailored, smooth-talking agents of the Norfolk and Western had descended on southern West Virginia like locusts, their checking accounts fattened by funds from Philadelphia and across the sea in the City of London, and systematically bought up all the land they could lay their hands on. And not just the land. They were careful to secure the mineral rights, too. That was, after all, the point. On their heels came another invasion sponsored by the railroad. These men were a rougher sort, crude in dress and manner. They were construction workers, some 5,000 of them, and they set to work laying the Norfolk and Western trunk line, putting up more than sixty bridges and carving eight tunnels out of the Appalachian foothills, opening up the region and its fabulous deposits of coal. The 190 miles of tracks pushed through valleys of crooked streams penetrating a rugged wilderness that lacked even wagon roads. The hill country farmers turned away from their corn and beans, signed up for the mines and made their homes in cabins along the right of way. Their wives bought overalls and groceries in the company stores while their children played amidst the slag heaps that tarnished the once verdant land. Mules, horses and oxen hauled their work to the surface. Coal cars rumbled along the hillsides, dumping their loads at massive tipples, where it would be stored and then shipped out to markets around the country. Investors, well-fed men in rich tweeds and polished boots, came from all over to tour the valley, inspect the mines and lay out their money, certain of a bountiful return. The coal mines proliferated and thrived. No one could question the riches that lay beneath the earth. Some called the region the "El Dorado" of Appalachia.
Coal was big business, but now it was in big trouble. It was this crisis that called the Baldwin-Felts agents to Matewan. Baldwin-Felts prospered by doing the bidding of the coal companies of West Virginia, serving more or less as their private police force. Tom Felts was sending these men to Matewan, in Mingo County, because there, as in the rest of southern West Virginia, the coal companies, whose output fueled the national economy, and the United Mine Workers of America, the nation's most powerful labor union, were at each other's throats.
By this date, Wednesday, May 19, 1920, America had been at peace abroad for more than eighteen months. The last doughboys of the American Expeditionary Force had long since shipped out of Brest, bound for home, hoping to return to normalcy. The huzzahs from the victory parades on America's Main Streets had long since died out. But at home there was no peace between business and labor. The trade unions were up against it. During the war, with the help of Washington officialdom eager to keep production rolling, the unions had gained in prestige and numbers, gains that had translated into hard cash for the rank and file. But now labor was on the defensive. Struggling against rising prices, which shrunk their paychecks, and slumping demand, which threatened to take away their jobs altogether, many workers looked to their unions for salvation. But the nation's captains of industry would have none of that. Instead they were eager to reassert their prewar hegemony over the economy, rid the unions of their newfound illusions and power and boost their profits, already lifted by the war, to even greater heights. Looking at the world around them, the more prescient among the leaders of corporate America sensed that they were on the right side of history, at one of the great turning points in the nation's life story. The idealism that infused Woodrow Wilson's New Freedom and his crusade to make the world safe for democracy was in the process of being repudiated by a rigorous rightward shift, breathtaking in its scope. Its most conspicuous feature was the Red Scare launched by Wilson's own attorney general, A. Mitchell Palmer, which smothered dissent of all kinds. But the conservative trend was also marked by an enhanced reverence for free enterprise, its leaders and all their works, an attitude that served to reinforce the resistance of these worthies to the demands of labor.
The collision of labor's desperation with management's intransigence had triggered an unprecedented wave of strikes, more than 3,000 walkouts all told in 1919 involving more than four million workers. Steelworkers "hit the bricks," as did coal miners and printers. Even police walked off the job. "I really think we are facing a desperate situation," worried the normally sanguine junior senator from Ohio, Warren Harding. "It looks to me as if we are coming to crisis in the conflict between the radical labor leaders and the capitalistic system under which we have developed the Republic."
The following year, 1920, brought no letup in strife. Labor tensions mounted around the land, but nowhere were the stakes as high as in West Virginia on the day that Tom Felts dispatched his men to Matewan. Their journey was only fifty miles and took little more than an hour. But it would open a new and bloody chapter in the annals of American history. Their arrival would set off a chain reaction of violence that would rock the government of West Virginia to its foundations and at the same time challenge the Federal government in Washington, testing the will and nerve of the highest officials of the nation. It would take months to run its course and conclude only after 10,000 armed miners set out to defy the government of the state and the companies that controlled their lives in the largest armed uprising on American soil since the Civil War.
It was no accident that this upheaval would burst forth when and where it did, in Matewan in Mingo County. This county was the center of West Virginia's richest coalfield. Within twenty-five miles of the county seat, Williamson, about seventy-five mines produced twelve million tons of bituminous a year, a healthy share of total national production. Nearly all these mines were non-union, many opened during the past few years to meet the nation's growing demand for coal during the war.
When the war ended, the mines remained, productive and unorganized, to threaten the UMW's power elsewhere in the country by selling coal at a discount against the prices charged by unionized operators. Unless the UMW could organize all of West Virginia, the union's leaders realized, the nationwide strength it had spent nearly half a century building would dwindle and eventually disappear.
Sprawling beyond Mingo's borders, the Williamson Field reached across the Tug Fork of the Big Sandy River into Kentucky's Pike County to the west, and into the West Virginia counties of McDowell to the south and Logan to the east. Indeed, the coal seams in Logan were even richer than in Mingo and the mines employed more than twice as many men.
But Logan was the base of the mine operators' power. The operators subsidized Logan County Sheriff Don Chafin's department; in return Chafin's deputies did all they could to protect them against the union and its organizers. Outrage over the sheriff's strong-arm tactics had boiled over in the summer of 1919, about nine months before the Baldwin-Felts agents boarded the train for Matewan. Union headquarters in the state capital of Charleston, about fifty miles north of the Williamson field, seethed with stories that Chafin's deputies were beating and murdering the organizers the UMW had dispatched to Logan County, trying to cut out the boil that threatened its welfare and future. On Thursday September 4, angry miners began gathering in the town of Marmet, on the outskirts of Charleston, for a march on Logan County. By the next day, Friday, September 5, their numbers had grown to 5,000. Most were armed to the teeth.
This was enough to get West Virginia Governor John J. Cornwell to rush to the scene. Cornwell, a newspaper editor turned politician, had been elected on the Democratic ticket in 1916 with the help of miner support. He had won their votes by promising to give the UMW a fair hearing and curb the excesses of the guards hired by the coal operators. "Boys throw your support to me and I will do everything in my power to remove the gunmen from the state," Fred Mooney, secretary treasurer of District 17, which represented most of West Virginia's union miners, recalled the candidate saying. Cornwell had made token efforts to keep his promise, but in the judgment of the union men he had not done nearly enough. Actually Mooney, like other union leaders, believed that the mine guard system was so deeply entrenched that "only a superman, such as Oliver Cromwell or Napoleon Bonaparte would have been able to prevent its functioning."
Far from being a superman, Cornwell was only a hack officeholder and a journeyman orator, as he demonstrated when he arrived at Marmet on Friday in the dead of night and clambered on top of a soft drink truck to address the rebels. They crowded around the impromptu podium, and with the moonlight glistening on their gun barrels listened to Cornwell with fast-diminishing patience. Mindful that many in his audience had fought under their country's flag in France, Cornwell appealed to them as patriots and law-abiding citizens. "Boys do you not know that everyone of you is acting in violation of every law against bearing arms and that you are taking the law into your own hands?" he demanded.
That argument did not impress. "There is no law in West Virginia except the law of the coal operators," one miner shouted.
Ignoring him, Cornwell pressed on, vowing to crack down on the mine owners and their guards if only the rebels would take their rifles and go home. But those promises had an all too familiar ring to the miners. They heard Cornwell out, but when he finished and headed back to Charleston, they signaled their defiance by firing their weapons in the air, the din drowning out the protesting voices of Fred Mooney and the president of District 17, Frank Keeney.
Cornwell got the message. Back at the capital on Saturday, September 6, the governor put through a call to President Wilson's Secretary of War, Newton Baker, and asked for Federal troops to deal with the incipient rebellion. Since the birth of the Republic such requests had been considered a serious departure from constitutional norms and had required presidential approval. But when state national guards were called to the colors after the United States plunged into the Great War, worries mounted that governors would not be able to cope with domestic disturbances. To help them out in such emergencies, the intervention process had been simplified and expedited by eliminating the requirement for direct presidential involvement. Under the emergency policy known as "direct access," once Baker heard from Cornwell, he bypassed the Oval Office and instead sent word of the threatened uprising directly to General Leonard Wood. Wood, who had won his first star fighting Aguinaldo's guerrillas in the Philippines at the turn of the century, had been deemed too old for duty with the AEF in France. Instead he had been given command of the troops assigned to deal with labor disputes and other domestic disorders. Looking ahead to his prospects for gaining the 1920 Republican presidential nomination, Wood was eager for action and public attention. Within a few hours he reported to Baker that a force of 1,600 men had been assembled and was ready to march.
Informed of the deployment by Cornwell, Mooney and Keeney realized they faced the toughest challenge of their dual stewardship of District 17. Along with their Irish heritage they shared a common upbringing. Both had been raised in the mining camps of the state, worked in the mines since they were boys and joined the union early on. And both had been bloodied in the Paint Creek–Cabin Creek strike of 1912–1913. Back then thousands of miners in the Kanawha Valley, just north of the Williamson Field, walked out demanding higher wages and recognition of their union, leading to what was, up to that time, the cruelest and most protracted dispute in West Virginia labor history. Keeney, sharp featured and square jawed, at thirty-five was the older by three years, the more articulate and the more aggressive. He was a quick thinker and also quick to anger. In 1912 he had fought against the local leadership's initial attempt to settle the Paint Creek–Cabin Creek strike as offering only meager gains to the union and for his pains was blacklisted.
But he returned in 1916 to take command of a full-scale revolt by members of the local who condemned District 17's leaders as "drunkards and crooks," then seceded, and formed their own local.
The lean, sallow-faced Mooney, though more deliberative and restrained than Keeney, was no shrinking violet himself. He too had attacked the original Paint Creek–Cabin Creek settlement proposal and after the strike finally concluded, had helped to foment the rebellion against the District 17 hierarchy. In the midst of his travails his wife died, leaving him to care for their three young children. Nevertheless Mooney along with Keeney pressed their insurgency. Ultimately an investigation by the national union confirmed their charges that the rulers of the local had sold out the rank and file during contract negotiations to line their own pockets. When District 17 elected new officers Keeney and Mooney agreed that Keeney, because he had led the secession movement, would seek the president's job, while Mooney would run for secretary-treasurer.
The two were strong willed but they were not pigheaded. Pondering the warning from Cornwell that the Army was on the way they realized they had no choice but to stop the march. They spent that day alternating between frantic phone conversations to Charleston, pleading with Cornwell for more time, and frantic speeches to their members, urging them to listen to reason. Finally, armed with a fresh promise from Cornwell to appoint a commission, headed by West Virginia's adjutant general, Thomas B. Davis, to investigate the allegations against the mine owners, the union men heeded the urgings of their leaders and agreed to disband.
Hopes for Cornwell's inquiry, never too bright to begin with, were further dimmed almost immediately. He seemed to give little weight to the miners' complaints. Instead, the governor told the New York Times that "some mysterious radical influence" was responsible for the march, sparking what he described as "false reports" of the rumors of atrocities against the union organizers. A fortnight after his interview with the Times, addressing a trade association convention in White Sulphur Springs, Cornwell underlined his suspicions of the labor movement, warning that radical labor leaders were at work on a deliberate plan to overthrow the government and install a communist system. "They do not intend to try to have their policies put into force through a popular vote," he said. "That would be too slow," and it would never happen. Laying the groundwork for the conspiracy, Cornwell said, was the union drive to shorten the work week, which he argued would inevitably reduce production and raise prices.
Genre:
- On Sale
- Jul 26, 2006
- Page Count
- 304 pages
- Publisher
- Basic Books
- ISBN-13
- 9780786735945
Newsletter Signup
By clicking ‘Sign Up,’ I acknowledge that I have read and agree to Hachette Book Group’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use